Commercial Disputes and Pre-Action Strategy

See the commercial position before choosing the next move.

Independent assessment and practical strategy for businesses facing a commercial dispute, payment problem, contested contract or property-related disagreement before litigation.

Evidence ledPre-action focusedHuman reviewed

Clarity before escalation

Turn a complicated dispute into a business decision.

Pressure to respond quickly can hide the decision that actually needs to be made.

We organise the facts and documents, identify evidential strengths and gaps, assess money and relationships at risk, and compare settlement, negotiation, escalation and referral options. The aim is a proportionate strategy grounded in the material that is available.

Four defined services

Choose the support that fits the decision in front of you.

Each service has a clear purpose and deliverable. The final scope reflects the dispute, document volume, urgency and complexity.

01

Dispute Clarity Review

Turn a complicated dispute into an organised and understandable picture.

Typical use cases

  • You are unsure whether to pursue a claim or dispute
  • You have received a complaint, demand or allegation
  • People within the business give different accounts
  • The documents are extensive or disorganised
  • You are unsure whether to negotiate, investigate further or escalate
  • You want an independent assessment before instructing solicitors

Included

  • Review of the agreed core documents
  • Initial chronology
  • Principal parties and issues
  • Summary of each side’s apparent position
  • Evidence inventory and gap analysis
  • Preliminary financial exposure
  • Commercial objectives and constraints
  • Immediate priorities
  • Decision meeting
DeliverableDispute Clarity Report & Initial Action List
Not included

Formal merits opinion; Representation; Court documents or proceedings; Expert evidence; Extensive legal research unless expressly included.

02

Pre-Action Strategy Plan

Convert your position into a proportionate pre-action plan.

Typical use cases

  • You understand the dispute but need a structured next step
  • Correspondence has stalled
  • Evidence must be secured or obtained
  • A settlement proposal, formal response or escalation plan is required
  • You need to prepare efficiently for possible solicitor involvement

Included

  • Focused review of relevant facts and documents
  • Refined chronology and issue map
  • Evidential strengths, weaknesses and uncertainties
  • Financial exposure or recovery analysis
  • Commercial leverage assessment
  • Pre-action options and recommended sequence
  • Evidence-preservation and information-gathering plan
  • Settlement and escalation triggers
  • Draft correspondence for your approval and issue
  • Solicitor referral criteria
  • Strategy meeting
DeliverableWritten Pre-Action Strategy Plan
03

Settlement & Mediation Preparation

Prepare to negotiate from an informed and commercially coherent position.

Typical use cases

  • A settlement discussion or mediation is approaching
  • You need clear negotiating parameters
  • Financial and non-financial outcomes must be compared
  • Likely counterarguments and concessions need to be tested

Included

  • Settlement objectives and best, acceptable and walk-away outcomes
  • Financial scenario analysis
  • Non-financial priorities
  • Leverage and concession analysis
  • Negotiation sequencing
  • Opening and fallback positions
  • Evidence and document summary
  • Anticipated counterarguments
  • Draft settlement proposals for you to issue
  • Mediation preparation meeting
  • Attendance as a non-legal commercial adviser where agreed and permitted
DeliverableA clear negotiation or mediation position, supported by the agreed preparation materials
Not included

Advocacy as a solicitor or barrister; Authority to settle unless separately and expressly documented; Instruments requiring reserved or specialist regulated input; Giving undertakings on your behalf.

04

Independent Settlement Review

Provide an independent review of the evidence and formulate a commercially reasoned settlement proposal.

Typical use cases

  • You need an objective view before proposing or accepting settlement
  • The evidence, exposure and escalation risks need to be compared
  • Decision-makers need a reasoned settlement range or structure

Included

  • Independent review of the agreed material
  • Principal factual and evidential issues
  • Uncertainties and information gaps
  • Financial and operational exposure
  • Settlement and escalation scenarios
  • Recommended settlement range or structure
  • Proposed settlement approach
  • Decision meeting
DeliverableIndependent assessment and a commercially reasoned settlement approach
Not included

An assurance of legal success; A prediction of the court’s decision.

Pricing

Clear starting points for each stage of a dispute.

All prices exclude VAT. The agreed scope, document limits, assumptions and fee are confirmed before substantive work begins.

01

Dispute Clarity Review

Small Claim Clarity ReviewStreamlined review for a matter ordinarily valued below £10,000
From £395
Standard Clarity ReviewOne principal dispute and up to approximately 150 core pages
From £850
Enhanced Clarity ReviewMultiple issues, parties or a larger document set
From £1,750
Complex ReviewHigh-value, multi-party or technically complex; individually costed
Usually from £3,500
02

Pre-Action Strategy Plan

Focused Strategy PlanOne defined issue or commercial decision
From £1,500
Full Pre-Action Strategy PlanComplete strategy for a standard commercial dispute
From £2,750
Complex Strategic Case SupportMulti-party, high-value or document-heavy matter
From £5,000
03

Settlement & Mediation Preparation

Settlement Preparation — focusedFocused preparation for settlement discussions
From £1,250
Full Mediation Preparation PackComprehensive preparation for mediation
From £2,500
Complex or multi-party preparationFor wider, high-value or multi-party matters
From £4,500
Half-day mediation attendanceNon-legal commercial adviser attendance where agreed
From £950 + expenses
Full-day mediation attendanceNon-legal commercial adviser attendance where agreed
£1,750 + expenses
04

Independent Settlement Review

Standard independent reviewReview of a standard commercial dispute
From £1,750
Complex, high-value or multi-party reviewIndividually scoped to the matter
From £3,500

Standard commercial rates

Additional work and expedited delivery.

Additional work£250 + VAT per hour
Half-day advisory or attendance£950 + VAT
Full-day advisory, mediation or workshop£1,750 + VAT
Expedited delivery in 2–3 working days35% uplift, minimum £350

Monthly retainers

Ongoing capacity for active matters.

Managed and portfolio retainers ordinarily have a three-month minimum term.

Litigation Guidance

£1,350 + VAT per monthUp to 6 hours

Regular access and limited document review

Managed Matter

£2,550 + VAT per monthUp to 12 hours

Ongoing management of one principal dispute

Dispute Portfolio

£4,800 + VAT per monthUp to 24 hours

Several disputes, contracts or debt matters

Strategic Capacity

From £7,500 + VAT per monthUp to 40 hours

Additional senior dispute-management capacity

Travel, venues, external databases and third-party professional fees are quoted separately. Expedited work is subject to capacity and suitability.

How it works

Start with the issue, deadline and principal documents.

01

Initial triage

Provide a short summary, identify all parties and disclose any urgent deadline.

02

Suitability review

We assess the dispute stage, documents, complexity and any need for formal representation.

03

Defined engagement

You receive the scope, exclusions, pricing and target delivery period before work begins.

04

Strategy and next steps

We deliver the agreed analysis and practical priorities, including referral where required.

Scope of Work

Pre-action support with clear boundaries.

We accept only work that fits our competence, insurance, capacity and non-reserved consultancy scope.

Usually suitable
  • Commercial contract and payment disputes
  • B2B debt recovery or response strategy
  • Property and landlord-and-tenant disputes before proceedings
  • Settlement and mediation preparation
  • Evidence, chronology and commercial exposure reviews
Individually assessed
  • High-value, complex or multi-party disputes
  • Matters involving several contracts or large document sets
  • Urgent deadlines or parallel regulatory concerns
  • Matters already involving external solicitors
  • Ongoing non-reserved support after referral
Outside scope
  • Conduct of litigation or going on the court record
  • Court advocacy or reserved legal activities
  • Criminal, family, immigration or private consumer matters
  • Instructions requiring misleading or improper conduct
  • Work outside England and Wales or outside confirmed insurance

Responsible intelligence

Technology supports the analysis. Judgement remains human.

Approved technology may help organise documents and identify issues. Every substantive output is reviewed before delivery. We state evidential gaps, assumptions, limitations and referral points openly.

Frequently Asked Questions

Before you send the documents.

Is this legal representation?

No. McKenzie-AI provides independent commercial dispute assessment and pre-action strategy. It does not go on the court record, conduct litigation or represent clients in court.

When should I make an enquiry?

Ideally, before proceedings are issued and before an important pre-action, settlement or commercial decision is made. Tell us immediately about any response, limitation, hearing or procedural deadline.

What documents should I provide?

Start with the principal contract, material correspondence, invoices or payment records, any formal letters and a short chronology. We will identify what else is needed after initial triage.

Can you draft letters or settlement proposals?

Where within scope, we may prepare wording for you to approve and send in your own name. We do not communicate as your solicitor or conduct litigation.

What happens if proceedings are required?

We will identify the referral point and recommend that you obtain advice or representation from an appropriately authorised solicitor. Non-reserved commercial support may continue only where separately agreed and appropriate.

How are retainers used?

A retainer provides defined monthly access and capacity. The precise work, response expectations, exclusions and any minimum term are confirmed before instruction.

Start with clarity

Tell us what is creating commercial pressure.

Provide a short summary, the current stage and any urgent deadline. Contact details are available on the main McKenzie-AI page.

View contact detailsAn enquiry does not create a client relationship. Please do not send unusually sensitive material until requested.